Why Physicians Deserve a Say in Their 1099 Classification

Why Physicians Deserve a Say in Their 1099 Classification

A recent White Coat Investor blog tackled a common question from hospital employed physicians who wondered whether they could choose to work as 1099 independent contractors instead of W2 employees. Dr James Dahle delivered a clear and conservative answer. He argued that employment classification is not optional, that most hospital physicians fit the IRS definition of employees, and that organizations offering “1099 choice” are skating on thin legal ice.

While technically accurate, this framing misses a deeper truth that independent physicians have understood for decades. It treats medicine as a rigid workforce model rather than a flexible professional marketplace where clinicians can operate as businesses, not just employees.

As someone who has lived and practiced as a 1099 physician for nearly 15 years, I see this debate in an entirely different light. It is not primarily about taxes. It is about ownership of your professional identity.

The Core Issue Agency Not Avoidance

Independent contractor status is not a loophole, it’s the innate agency power you have as a licensed medical professional in the marketplace to choose to be an employee or non-employee. You have earned that right and no one should have the power to strip of this. It is a legitimate professional pathway long used by physicians in locums, telemedicine, consulting, anesthesia, radiology, emergency medicine, concierge medicine, private practice, and hybrid careers. My personal favorite is emloyment lite which is a hybrid between private practice and employment.

Physicians do not pursue 1099 work to skirt taxes. They pursue it to regain:

• control of their schedule

• freedom to choose clients

• autonomy over workflow

• the ability to build a micro business

• the right to form their own professional corporation

• agency that is earned by being a licensed professional

The barrier is rarely the IRS. The barrier is institutional paternalism. What they are blocking is your hard earned professional autonomy.

Hospitals default to W2 classification not because all physicians “must be” employees but because it simplifies administration and eliminates the need to understand physician entrepreneurship.

Your Autonomy & Agency

Many of you don’t realize that agency and autonomy are two different parts of the independence equation. Autonomy is the freedom and ability you have to structure your work, choose your contracts, and operate as a business. Agency is your capacity to use that freedom with confidence & clarity in concert with your willingness to act. Sadly, in today’s broken healthcare system, too many doctors are conditioned to blindly believe that they no longer possess professional autonomy or agency.

You can have autonomy without agency when you technically have options but feel overwhelmed or unsure of how to move. You can have agency without autonomy when you feel ready to act but are trapped in a rigid W2 structure that gives you no real room to maneuver.

My PEA mission is to inspire you to reach the point where both your professional agency and autonomy exist at the same time. Where you feel empowered to design your work life and have the structural freedom to carry it out. This is exactly what legitimate 1099 work, Independent Contracting, and Employment Lite models restore.

If you want a deeper grounding in how independence really works, download the PEA resource Independent Contracting for Physicians Freedom Flexibility and Financial Control — a guide that breaks down the structures and protections that make true independence possible.

What the IRS Actually Cares About

The IRS does not prohibit independent contractor physicians. Rather they inform employers to determine whether a worker is an employee vs independent contractor based on three categories:

Behavioral control

Who Determines the Methods, Timing, and Manner of Work for Physicians?

When it comes to the daily responsibilities of physicians, understanding who controls the methods, timing, and manner in which you work is crucial. In most clinical settings—such as hospitals, large healthcare systems, or group practices—the employer or supervising entity typically sets these parameters. This means that you often follow established protocols for patient care, adhere to scheduled shifts or rounds set by their institution, and practice medicine according to guidelines determined by medical boards and organizational leadership.

However, it’s important to recognize that physicians retain a significant degree of autonomy within these structures. While administrative policies may dictate when and how certain tasks are performed—such as appointment scheduling or documentation requirements—physicians ultimately use their expertise to make critical decisions about patient care. Their training empowers them to determine the best course of action in diagnosis and treatment within the boundaries set by ethical standards and institutional policy.

In private practices or independent settings, physicians have even greater control over their work methods and schedules. They can establish office hours that suit their preferences and implement personalized approaches to patient care. Regardless of setting though, all physicians must comply with broader regulatory standards designed to ensure quality care and patient safety.

Ultimately, while employers or governing bodies may influence many aspects of a physician’s work environment, it is the blend of institutional guidance with professional judgment that shapes how medicine is practiced every day. This balance ensures both consistency in healthcare delivery and respect for physician expertise—a combination that benefits patients above all else.

And in the end, maintaining the professional autonomy to make clinical decisions within patient care points you in the direction of independence regardless of the practice management constraints associated with working in a healthcare system owned by someone else.

Financial control

Understanding the Differences: Employed Physicians vs. Independent Contractors

As you finish your training and enter the marketplace, you are faced the choice between becoming employed by a healthcare organization or choosing the various forms of self-employment that include working as an independent contractor. This decision has significant implications for risk, expenses, billing, collections, and access to necessary tools or equipment.

Employed physicians typically enjoy greater financial security and stability. The hospital or medical group assumes most of the business risks and covers overhead expenses such as malpractice insurance, office space, administrative support, and medical equipment. Billing and collections are handled by the employer’s established systems—physicians focus on patient care while the organization manages payment logistics.

In contrast, independent contractor physicians shoulder more responsibility but may gain increased flexibility and earning potential. As contractors, they are responsible for their own business risks—covering malpractice insurance premiums themselves and often supplying or leasing their own tools or medical equipment. Billing for professional services can be managed independently or through third-party services; however, it is ultimately up to the contractor to ensure timely collection of payments for their services rendered to the healthcare company employing them. This includes paying self-employment taxes that are not automatically removed from your paycheck. Typically the billing and collections for the professional services you render to patients are the responsibility of the employing healthcare company—not you as the contractor.

Ultimately, employed positions offer security with fewer administrative burdens but less autonomy. Independent contracting offers freedom but demands greater business acumen and acceptance of risk. Knowing who carries risk, pays expenses & benefits, handles billing/collections—and who provides essential resources—can empower physicians to make informed decisions about their professional path.

Relationship structure

Employed Physicians vs. Independent Contractors: Understanding the Service Agreement and Employment Relationship

When it comes to your working arrangements, distinguishing between an employment relationship and independent contractor status is crucial. Employed physicians typically have a defined service agreement that outlines their duties, compensation, benefits, and expectations within a structured employer-employee relationship. This arrangement often means the physician works exclusively for one organization, receives employee benefits like health insurance and retirement plans, and has less control over their schedule.

In contrast, when you form a corporate entity—such as an sole proprietorship, PLLC or professional corporation—you operate with a high degree of autonomy. These independent contractor business structures allow you to work for multiple clients or healthcare facilities, often require you to carry your own malpractice insurance, set your own hours, negotiate fees directly with clients, and manage your own business expenses. Such characteristics clearly meet the IRS criteria for 1099 status.

The distinction is more than just semantics; it impacts tax obligations, liability coverage, scheduling flexibility, and overall job satisfaction. This autonomy all adds up to a greater sense of well being for many doctors. If you are seeking greater control over your career—especially if you are comfortable managing business operations—the independent contractor path offers measurable autonomy while allowing you to diversify income streams across various clients. In fact this latter element of having more than one professional income streams (or having the option) is often considered one of the litmus tests for being called an independent contractor.

Ultimately, understanding whether your arrangement constitutes an employer-employee relationship or a true independent contractor agreement is essential for legal compliance and professional fulfillment in today’s evolving healthcare landscape.

Summary of Control Evaluation

If you’re looking for control over your professional life as a physician—and are willing to take on additional responsibilities—operating as an independent contractor under a clearly defined professional services agreement is not only possible but highly advantageous in today’s evolving healthcare landscape.

If you form a corporate entity work and for multiple clients, carry your own insurance, control your schedules, and operate with measurable autonomy clearly you meet the 1099 standard.

Professionals like attorneys, engineers, accountants, and business consultants all operate this way. Physicians are no different.

Employment Lite The Middle Ground That Works

Because traditional employment is too restrictive and pure independence can feel overwhelming I often guide physicians toward a middle ground I call the Employment Lite Model. This is beautiful hybrid model between traditional employment and private practice—where you function as a long term independent contractor for a healthcare employer.

This structure:

• uses a scope of professional services agreement (PSA) instead of an employment contract

• pays physicians per wRVU or per hour

• allows physicians to contract through their own PC or PLLC

• avoids employer provided benefits

• allows multiple simultaneous contracts

• supports many forms of self-employment that include telemedicine, locums, hybrid part time, and consulting work such as medical-legal work. Essentially you can job stack in any form you desire.

The employment lite model satisfies IRS expectations for you being considered an independent contractor, while giving you the autonomy they need to build a sustainable career—that avoiding the burnout epidemic—that I largely attribute to traditional employment models.

Why 1099 Fear Is Overblown

Organizations invoke “IRS risk” as a reason to block physician independence. But the IRS focuses on abusive misclassification not legitimate professionals operating real businesses.

Physicians with:

• a corporation

• multiple contracts

• control over workflow

• responsibility for their own insurance

• clearly defined non employee relationships

rarely face reclassification. The IRS even offers employers and contractors a formal review process through Form SS 8 for uncertain situations.

The statement “all doctors must be W2 employees” has no basis in IRS code.

Why Physicians Should Care

Independent contracting opens doors that traditional employment cannot.

Financial benefits Business deductions, control over expenses, significant retirement planning flexibility

Professional advantages Control over schedule, practice environment, contractual terms, and business mobility

Identity shift You are no longer labor. You are a professional business delivering specialized services.

Career longevity Independence gives physicians the adaptability needed to survive system changes without sacrificing autonomy.

This framework is not a threat to medicine. It is a lifeline. The marketplace pendulum needs to swing back towards preserving your personal and professional autonomy. That swing begins with you being empowered to make your own decision about your employment classification as either W-2 or 1099.

The Real Problem Paternalistic Employers

Many institutions rely on one size fits all staffing models that favor control rather than collaboration. They claim IRS risk but mean administrative convenience.

By refusing to allow physicians to structure their work as independent contractors even when they are fully compliant with IRS rules for contractors, employers limit physician autonomy, financial literacy, and professional choice.

The solution is simple Let physicians choose a legitimate model and document it correctly.

Lessons from the Field

One of my clients whom I will call Dr Menon practiced for years as a W2 hospitalist. She felt exhausted by rigid scheduling and trapped by a compensation plan she could not influence.

We transitioned her into an Employment Lite structure using her own micro corporation. She contracted with three telemedicine groups plus occasional locums shifts.

In 18 months she:

• reduced clinical hours by 30 percent

• increased income by 40 percent

• eliminated mandatory holidays

• and gained complete schedule control

Her employer did not “grant” independence. She built it herself using the tools she had never been taught.

Tool of the Week

To understand how independent work fits into the medical marketplace download the PEA resource 👉 Independent Contracting for Physicians Freedom Flexibility and Financial Control It explains the business structures workflows and financial advantages that allow physicians to operate as true professionals rather than controlled employees.

If you want to explore specific settings that support 1099 work also review 👉 Job Options for Independent Physicians Breaking Free from Corporate Medicine

Scale with Coaching

If you want help building a compliant path to independence evaluating 1099 eligibility or designing an Employment Lite model you can work with me directly.

Micro-Business Coaching 4 Pack

Perfect for entity structure contracting and early business formation.

Business Enterprise Coaching 4 Pack

Ideal for financial optimization and strategic career expansion.

Business Consultation

If you need focused guidance on building your independence pathway schedule a consultation.

Business Strategy Session $500

Take a deep dive with me into the classification and contracting options strategically available to you in the marketplace.This is your chance to be emancipated from the control of a large corporate employer.

OR

One Time Micro-Business Consultation $299

Targeted support for you if you are exploring independence or hybrid arrangements.